Longshots Bar and Grill, up close
If you know me, you know I spend a lot of time chasing good bar food around Michiana. Longshots Bar and Grill is a place I stop for a quick lunch or an easy night out. Longshots Bar and Grill sits at 117 E Michigan St in New Carlisle, and it has a 4.6 rating from 293 reviews, so people like it for what it is: casual food, cold beer, cocktails, and friendly staff.
Is this the best bar & grill in New Carlisle?
Depends on what you want. If you want a comfortable, unpretentious spot with pizzas, burgers, chili and weekend prime rib, Longshots fits. Price-wise expect around $10-20 for most plates. It is a bar & grill restaurant in New Carlisle that leans casual and cozy, with bar seating and table service when you prefer it.
When to go
They’re closed Monday. On weekdays they open for lunch at 11:30 AM and generally close around 8:30 PM most days, with Thursday staying open later until 9:30 PM. Saturday is a later day, noon to 10 PM, and Sunday is an afternoon service from 2 to 8 PM. If you want weekend prime rib, plan for a weekend visit.
What the place feels like
Casual and cozy is the right description. There’s a bar onsite, some outdoor seating when weather cooperates, and the staff move fast. You’ll find bar games and live performances sometimes, and sports on the TVs when there’s something worth watching. It’s often popular for lunch, dinner, and solo dining, so you won’t feel out of place eating alone at the bar.
Practical details and perks
- Address and phone: 117 E Michigan St, New Carlisle, IN 46552. Call (574) 988-0176.
- Payment: credit, debit, NFC mobile payments accepted.
- Parking: free parking lot and free street parking, usually plenty of spots.
- Accessibility: wheelchair accessible entrance, parking, restroom and seating.
- Service options: takeout, dine-in, outdoor seating, and they accept reservations.
Drinks and the bar
They keep a solid beer selection and some good cocktails, plus hard liquor and wine. There’s a relaxed happy hour vibe at times, and because it’s built around the bar, you can expect quick service for drinks and smaller plates if that’s what you want.
Who goes here
You’ll see groups, locals, and tourists passing through. The place works for a quick, no-fuss meal or an evening with a few friends. I’ve taken people here who wanted a straightforward spot without fuss. If you’re searching for a bar & grill near me while passing through New Carlisle or driving out from South Bend, Longshots will give you a reliable meal and a friendly server.
Why locals like it
People praise the fast service and the friendly staff. Some nights there are live performances and there’s usually something on the TVs, so it’s one of those community places that feels familiar after a visit or two. It’s listed among local Michiana restaurants that make it easy to get a decent bite without overthinking your night.
Planning a visit: what to expect
If you want a quick bite at the bar or a sit-down dinner, Longshots handles both. It serves comfort food and small plates, and you can grab food late on some nights. They also do catering, if you need food for a small event. For details and the latest updates, check the Longshots Bar and Grill page on Venture Michiana: Longshots Bar and Grill.
Looking for other options nearby
If you want to compare places, browse more Michiana restaurants on our site: All Venture Michiana restaurants. There are several spots within a short drive of South Bend if you’re planning a fuller evening out.
Where to stay nearby
If you’re making a weekend of it, here are a couple of places I’d recommend that are a short drive from New Carlisle. Both are comfortable and convenient for hitting local restaurants.
- Clover Haven, a one bedroom option that’s easy to reach from New Carlisle and central to the area.
- Urban Nest, another one bedroom pick, handy if you want to be closer to downtown activity.
For a full list of where to stay while you’re exploring, see our stays page: All Venture Michiana stays.
Final take
Longshots Bar and Grill is the kind of place you go when you want solid comfort food, decent drink options, and friendly, fast service without pretension. It does what a bar and grill should: good beer, simple food that hits the spot, and a relaxed room to eat in. If you’re weighing where to eat in New Carlisle, Longshots deserves a spot on the list.
Thinking of a short trip to Michiana? Book direct and save. Stay with Venture Michiana at Clover Haven or Urban Nest, or see all our options on the stays page and pick the one that fits your visit.